Thursday, April 19, 2007


Like many, I am saddened and sickened by the Virginia Tech mass murder. What is more disturbing than the incident itself, is the coverage the murderer is receiving as a result. I'm referring to the latest development, the gunman's manifesto received by NBC which has subsequently aired frequently in many reports.

Do we as viewers, family members or students need to understand in video or photo format just how disturbed this man really was? Don't the callous slayings speak for themselves? Isn't the airing of this footage glorifying the crime this sick person committed? And to a larger degree, does it not give others a fresh idea to add to any of their potential fantasies of acting out in a sadistic rage?

What I would have preferred was the anchor indicating that although NBC received such a package and immediately turned it over to authorities, they carefully considered the value in airing such a manifesto. That top executives at NBC decided not to air the footage or photos so as not to glorify and fulfill the last part of this perverse plan.

Describing this manifesto in words alone would be sufficient to get the point across (the point being how ill this guy really was). I can more than fill in the blanks as to how fucked up he was. To see him in all his glory on tv and hear his incoherent aggression only reminds me how much the media feeds off this sort of thing, and in effect spreads and fans the violence originally created.

Imagine the effect this must have on the victim's friends, family and fellow students. What must it be like for them to see and hear the last words from this disturbed mind? To see and hear a self-righteous "explanation" of the slaughters? In the midst of their grief, seeing and hearing from this sick mind could only add to the horror and trauma already inflicted. Hearing this bastard say, "This could have been avoided," is disgusting to say the least.

The loss of these individuals does not lose significance without video commentary. The effect of this crime is not any less profound without a picture. I imagined the horror well enough when I read how one girl played dead to avoid being shot, how others lay on the ground with their feet blocking a classroom door from the re-entry of the gunman, and still how another student tried to deny what his mind clearly recognized as the sound of gunfire coming from a nearby classroom only to finally realize fellow students were indeed being shot.

After working in the media for seven years, I am reminded again of my decision to leave a toxic industry and the people that continue to infect what we call "news". What will it take for networks and editors to make the right decision instead of a ratings decision?

While generally boycotting the news may make me less informed about current events, it also makes me less jaded and cynical about the world we live in. In the wake of such tragedy, all we can do is cling to the notion that the world and all of our existence is not summed up by one heinous act--even when it feels like it is.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Very well written post, Tiff.

Shawna & I talk about this sort of thing a lot. About how the 'news' is looked at by many as a 'Public Service'. But, like you said, for those of us who have worked in the news, we've seen first hand that decisions are not based on 'what would be good for the public', but instead on ratings. It's a business. That's it. Either the media needs to quit pretending it's not a business, or the public needs to view it for what it really is.
As for the tragedy...pure heartbreak. I haven't followed any of the news on it, and just the tidbits you posted of the different experiences is more than enough for me.

TJ said...

I get different reactions when I discuss this with people. Most feel like they want to see the footage of the gunman, but I don't think people realize how desensitized they are becoming to such violence.

Networks should not be giving a voice to these lunatics, nevermind giving this man an opportuntity to continue to affect people from beyond his death.

I'm avoiding any further coverage of this unless it's about remembering the people lost and how they will continue to be celebrated in life.

Anonymous said...

I'm avoiding any further coverage of this unless it's about remembering the people lost and how they will continue to be celebrated in life.

Here's a good place to start:

http://deusexmalcontent.blogspot.com/2007/04/and-all-that-could-have-been.html


rbo

Followers